This was the first time since their takeover by actors Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney that Wrexham faced Premier League opposition in the FA Cup — and they made history by claiming their first victory over a top-flight side in 26 years.
Early Dominance and a Two-Goal Cushion
Wrexham started brightly in front of a passionate home crowd and co-owner Ryan Reynolds in the stands. They took the lead through Liberato Cacace, who capitalized on sloppy defending from the visitors. Just minutes later, Ollie Rathbone doubled the advantage with a calm finish after a fortunate ricochet, punishing more loose play from Forest.
The first half exposed Nottingham Forest's struggles, particularly as manager Sean Dyche had rotated heavily — making eight changes from their recent Premier League win over West Ham — perhaps underestimating the cup magic at this lower-tier venue.
Forest Fight Back — But Wrexham Respond
Forest improved after the break with key introductions like Neco Williams, Morgan Gibbs-White, and Nicolas Dominguez at halftime. Igor Jesus pulled one back with a header, but Wrexham quickly restored their two-goal lead when captain Dominic Hyam headed in a superb free-kick from George Dobson.
The tie looked over, but substitute Callum Hudson-Odoi turned the game on its head. Entering in the second half, he scored twice — first in the 76th minute to make it 3-2, then with a stunning late volley in the 89th minute to force extra time. His brace, including a chest control and precise finish, kept Forest alive.
Extra time was tense but goalless, setting up the inevitable shootout.
Shootout Drama: Okonkwo the Hero
Wrexham held their nerve in the penalties. Arthur Okonkwo emerged as the match-winner, saving two Forest spot-kicks — including the decisive effort from young Omari Hutchinson. Wrexham converted theirs confidently (with successful efforts from Josh Windass, Callum Doyle, George Thomason, and Jay Rodriguez), securing a 4-3 shootout victory.
The scenes of celebration were electric, with players mobbing Okonkwo and the home faithful roaring in delight. It marked Wrexham's first Premier League scalp in the competition since 1999 and another milestone in their remarkable rise from non-league to the Championship.
Reactions and Reflections
Wrexham manager Phil Parkinson called it a "special" and "rollercoaster" night, praising his team's belief and highlighting the club's storied FA Cup history. He expressed delight that Reynolds witnessed the triumph firsthand.
In contrast, Nottingham Forest boss Sean Dyche was scathing about his side's first-half display, labeling it "unacceptable for the badge" and urging his players to reflect. Despite a spirited comeback, Forest — who reached the semi-finals last season — crashed out early, adding to their challenging campaign.
This result perfectly encapsulates the magic of the FA Cup: underdogs rising, late drama, and unforgettable moments. For Wrexham, it's fuel for their promotion push; for Forest, a painful reminder that cup competitions demand respect regardless of league status.
The Red Dragons now await Monday's fourth-round draw, while Nottingham Forest turn their focus back to Premier League survival. The 2025/26 FA Cup has already delivered a classic.